# Neumann vs Hankel function as solutions and why computer programs are not the same

It is well known that the solution of Bessel differential equation can be:

1) Bessel first kind, J, and Neumann, Y, (Bessel 2nd kind) or

2) two Hankel functions or

3) Bessel 1st kind, J, and Hankel, H (not commonly used )

In the attached paper, they used option 1:

if we use B*J+C*H values of B and C should change so the equation would remain

since H=J+i*Y

but when I tried to change to option 3. Results are not the same! why should not they be the same? did I do a mistake? if there is a mistake where?

I have the program written using both Neumann and Hankel to compare what went wrong?

The tasks will be to check:
1) Mathematical correctness
2) Compare programs

This is very important, the two programs that I need to compare contain only 12 lines of differences each is just a change from Neumann to Hankel

The real objective of the project is much simple:
1) If I can write the solution of a Bessel differential equation as B*J+C*Y where B, C are constants and J, Y are Bessel 1st kind and 2nd kind or Neumann then it can be written as D*J+E*H since H=J+1i*Y
in that case D*J+E*(J+1i*Y) is related so B=D+E and C=1i*E
2) Since number 1 is true then why the program does not work. It is very important to verify that my assumption in 1 is true Mathematically. The paper is just an example since it is very simple and all it matrices are written in appendix.
The project should not take a real Mathematical professional more than 30 minute.

Om arbejdsgiveren:
( 109 bedømmelser ) Orlando, Canada

Projekt-ID: #15791341

## 9 freelancers are bidding on average \$94 for this job

VolKa

Hi. I think I will be able to do this. Regards Relevant Skills and Experience Math, Matlab Proposed Milestones \$100 CAD - m1

(160 bedømmelser)
6.4
bchandra1955

CS domain engineer here Relevant Skills and Experience Pls discuss

(125 bedømmelser)
6.4
matlabtutor828

Hello, dear friend I am expert in matlab, mathematics, electrical engineering. I have a lot of experiences in many projects. I can do your task well. Thanks Relevant Skills and Experience matlab and mathematics, elect Mere

(15 bedømmelser)
3.7
marieea786

hi mechanical engineer here with experties in matlab you can inbox me i can assure you of quality work

(9 bedømmelser)
3.3
henrikrobin

I can complete your project in 5 hours. Sure. Relevant Skills and Experience maths. Proposed Milestones \$80 CAD - initial.

(7 bedømmelser)
2.4
howang2017

Hello, dear friend I am expert in matlab, mathematics, electrical engineering. I have a lot of experiences in many projects. I can do your task well. Thanks Relevant Skills and Experience mathematics, matlab, electric Mere

(2 bedømmelser)
2.2
EndersonFalcon

Hi, I am very gook making demostrations, between my made works i have the trasformation of a Foster chain circuit to a Cauer chain circuit. Contact to me. Best regards, Enderson J. Relevant Skills and Experience m Mere