
Closed
Posted
Paid on delivery
## Senior PCB / Electronics Engineer – Independent Final Review of Completed KiCad Board I am looking for an experienced electronics/PCB engineer to provide a **final independent second opinion** on a completed 4-layer PCB before I manufacture the first five assembled prototypes. **Budget: approximately £20–£30 fixed price.** This is **not a design-from-scratch job** and I am not expecting a lengthy formal engineering report for this budget. What I want is an experienced engineer to spend some focused time reviewing the completed design, identify any obvious or serious remaining risks, and tell me whether they would personally be comfortable sending the board for manufacture. ### Current status The board is **SP-MB1 Rev B.1** and has already undergone extensive development and one independent engineering review. It currently has: - KiCad ERC: 0 errors - PCB DRC: 0 errors - 0 unconnected items - Native KiCad 10 project - Final Gerbers/drill files - Final BOM and component placement files - 126 fitted component positions - 11 intentional DNP positions The previous independent engineer originally found three genuine issues involving: - W5500 crystal implementation - PoE isolation clearance - USB-C mechanical accessibility These were corrected in Rev B.1 and subsequently re-reviewed. The previous engineer's final conclusion was effectively: **Safe to manufacture five engineering prototypes, subject to a few first-article/order checks.** I would now like a **second engineer who has had no involvement with the project** to look at it independently and either increase my confidence or identify anything we have missed. ### Main hardware The PCB includes: - ESP32-S3-WROOM-1-N16R8 - Native USB-C - W5500 Ethernet - Taoglas TMJ6049BGNL integrated-magnetics/PoE RJ45 - Silvertel Ag9905MT isolated PoE module - TPS2121 USB/PoE power mux - AP63203Q 3.3 V buck converter - ADS1232 24-bit load-cell ADC - ST25R100 13.56 MHz NFC reader - External NFC antenna/matching network - Mixed analogue, digital, RF, Ethernet and power circuitry ### What I would like checked I am mainly interested in problems that could cause the first five boards to: - fail completely; - damage components; - fail to boot/program; - have unreliable USB, Ethernet or PoE; - have incorrect connector or footprint pinouts; - have serious analogue/load-cell problems; - have a fundamentally incorrect NFC implementation; - be assembled incorrectly; - be difficult or impossible to bring up. In particular, please pay attention to: - ESP32-S3 power, boot/reset and native USB - PoE implementation and isolation - TPS2121 USB/PoE power switching - W5500, crystal, Ethernet magnetics and RJ45 mapping - ADS1232/load-cell analogue section - ST25R100/NFC implementation - critical/custom footprints - polarity-sensitive components - BOM/footprint compatibility - obvious PCB layout or manufacturing problems There is **no need to redesign the PCB simply because you would personally have routed something differently**. I am only interested in changes that represent a meaningful risk to these first five prototype boards. ### Critical parts Please pay particular attention to: - **Taoglas TMJ6049BGNL** RJ45 - **Silvertel Ag9905MT** PoE module - **ST25R100-CMET** - **TPS2121** - **C109 KEMET A700X107M010ATE015** PoE output capacitor Some of these are intentionally locked to exact manufacturer part numbers. ### Previous review information I will provide: - native KiCad project - schematic and PCB - Gerbers/drills - BOM/CPL - previous engineer review - summary of the Rev B → Rev B.1 corrections - final validation information Please **do not simply assume the previous engineer was correct**. I specifically want another pair of eyes. ### Deliverable I do not need a large formal report. A concise written response is fine, but please include: 1. **Any issue you believe should genuinely stop me manufacturing the five boards** 2. Any significant risk you think I should know about 3. Any sensible first-article tests you recommend 4. A simple final answer: **“If this were your project, would you send these exact files for manufacture of five prototype boards — YES or NO?”** If NO, please explain exactly why. ### Who I am looking for Ideally you have practical experience with several of: - KiCad - ESP32 hardware - Ethernet / magnetics / W5500 - PoE - USB - switch-mode power - precision ADC/load-cell circuits - NFC/RFID - mixed-signal PCB layout I am looking for an **experienced electronics engineer**, not somebody who will simply run KiCad DRC and repeat the result back to me. ### When applying Please start your proposal with: **INDEPENDENT PCB REVIEW** Then briefly tell me: 1. Your PCB/electronics design experience 2. Which of PoE, Ethernet, ESP32, NFC and precision analogue you have worked with 3. Whether you can review native KiCad 10 files 4. Whether you have previously reviewed someone else's PCB before manufacture 5. Whether you can provide a clear YES/NO manufacturing recommendation I understand this budget does not buy a full multi-day engineering audit. I am looking for a focused, experienced second opinion on an already heavily reviewed and validated board before spending money on the first five prototypes.
Project ID: 40754718
57 proposals
Remote project
Active 11 hours ago
Set your budget and timeframe
Get paid for your work
Outline your proposal
It's free to sign up and bid on jobs
57 freelancers are bidding on average £140 GBP for this job

INDEPENDENT PCB REVIEW Greetings, On recent embedded hardware work I have reviewed boards around MCU bring-up, USB, power, sensors and mixed-signal interfaces, where the useful part was catching pinout, power-sequencing, footprint and bring-up risks rather than arguing about routing style. I also work close to firmware and board bring-up, so I tend to review with one practical question: will these five boards actually power, program and communicate correctly? I can review the native KiCad 10 project together with Gerbers, BOM/CPL and the previous review, and I have experience reviewing other engineers' PCB work before manufacture. My hands-on background is strongest around MCU/ESP32-type systems, USB, power and precision/sensor circuits; for PoE, Ethernet and NFC I would verify the exact parts against their datasheets and reference designs rather than simply trusting the earlier review. For £50 fixed I can do a focused review and return any stop-build issues, meaningful risks, first-article checks, and a clear YES/NO manufacturing recommendation within 2 hours. Sincerely, Oleksandr
£50 GBP in 1 day
8.4
8.4

Hi, I have experience in designing Circuits and can complete your project. I have expertise in the following: 1- Designing schematic and PCBA 2- Ordering the PCBA and getting boards manufactured. 3- Writing firmware for the PCBA to make sure everything works as expected. 4- I can also develop smartphone apps to communicate and control the hardware. If you wish we can discuss in chat. Thank you.
£205 GBP in 7 days
7.4
7.4

With over a decade in electronics, particularly PCB design, I'm confident that my skills will add invaluable rigor and objectivity to your project. I pay intricate attention to detail, which will be aiming at identifying any remaining risks that could be detrimental to the manufacturing of your first five prototypes. Having worked on analog designs like you have, the critical parts you expressed concerns about such as the Taoglas TMJ6049BGNL RJ45, Silvertel Ag9905MT PoE module and ST25R100-CMET shouldn't pose any problem for me. Over the years I have learned how important an independent second review can be, even with seemingly perfect designs as already confirmed by the previous engineer. Additionally, my expertise in using Altium and Easyeda will enable me to quickly dig into your KiCad project, schematics and Gerber's/drills without wasting any time. My role would be not only of a reviewer but also as your assurance, someone who can confidently say "immanufacture-appropriate". Moreover, the fact that I've been involved in projects around Digital Motor Control, Power-Electronics-AC/DC-ArcConvertors -Renewableenergy/invertors- indicates a capabilities to tackle complex challenges at system levels such as yours. Understanding higher-level system impact in a detailed and focused manner is my strength.
£100 GBP in 10 days
7.4
7.4

As an Electrical/Electronics Engineer with over 8 years of experience in PCB design and layout using Eagle, Altium, KiCAD, and EasyEDA, I'm confident I can provide the rigorous review you're seeking for your SP-MB1 Rev B.1 project. My vast experience in circuit design spanning mixed analog and power circuits makes me well-suited for scrutinizing your board's hardware composition including critical parts like Taoglas TMJ6049BGNL RJ45, Silvertel Ag9905MT PoE module, ST25R100-CMET, TPS2121, and C109 KEMET A700X107M010ATE015 PoE output capacitor. I am well-versed in reviewing projects with a focus on identifying potential areas of failure and risks that can affect board integrity and functionality. I comprehensively understand your call for multipronged checks including testing for complete failure, potential component damage, booting/programming failings, potential issues with USB/Ethernet/PoE connections and more. Trusting this project to me ensures that you're not getting a mere repetition of the initial review. Instead, you're entrusting your project to an experienced professional who thrives on exceeding client expectations by finding unique angles to problems. I assure you a high-quality and timely delivery of results that won’t break your budget! So let’s not leave anything to chance - let's get started on this final independent review and give you the utmost assurance in manufacturing those crucial initial prototypes.
£50 GBP in 7 days
7.0
7.0

INDEPENDENT PCB REVIEW I’m an experienced PCB/electronics engineer with practical experience in ESP32, Ethernet/W5500, PoE, USB, NFC/RFID, and mixed-signal PCB design. I can review your native KiCad 10 schematic, PCB, BOM, Gerbers, CPL, and previous review notes. I will focus on genuine risks, not simply repeat ERC/DRC results. I’ll carefully check power, boot/USB, PoE isolation, Ethernet, W5500, critical footprints, ADS1232, NFC, and BOM compatibility. I’ll also check for obvious manufacturing, assembly, polarity, and first-power-up risks. You will receive a concise list of any issues and recommended first-article tests. Most importantly, I’ll provide a clear YES/NO recommendation on manufacturing the five prototypes. I can complete this focused independent review Regards Engr Muhammad Usman
£195 GBP in 5 days
6.9
6.9

Hi there, I’m an Electronic Engineer with over 10 years’ experience designing embedded applications and their PCBs. I can review your native KiCad 10 files and provide an independent second opinion on the completed board, focusing on issues that could affect assembly, power, boot/programming, USB, Ethernet/PoE, load-cell measurements, or NFC. I’ll give you a concise summary of any significant risks, sensible first-article checks, and a clear YES/NO recommendation on whether I’d send these exact files for manufacture of five prototypes. How about a private message so we can discuss the project and the review materials? Kind regards, V.T.
£30 GBP in 1 day
6.7
6.7

Hi there, INDEPENDENT PCB REVIEW — I carefully reviewed your request for a focused second opinion on the completed SP-MB1 Rev B.1 before committing to the first five assembled prototypes, with particular attention to ESP32-S3, USB-C, W5500 Ethernet, PoE, power switching, precision load-cell acquisition, NFC, footprints, BOM compatibility, and manufacturing risks. I am a mechatronics engineer with almost half a decade of experience in electronics design, multilayer PCB layout, embedded systems, power supplies, mixed-signal circuitry, hardware prototyping, and interfaces such as USB, SPI, I2C, SDIO, and PCIe. I regularly work at schematic and PCB level using Altium Designer and understand the type of cross-checking required beyond simply relying on ERC/DRC results. For this review, I would focus specifically on issues that could realistically prevent bring-up, damage hardware, cause interface failures, create assembly problems, or justify stopping manufacture of the five prototypes. I can provide a concise risk-focused review and a clear YES/NO manufacturing recommendation rather than suggesting unnecessary redesigns based on personal layout preferences. Please send me a message so we can discuss the project and start. Best regards, Samuel tshibangu
£135 GBP in 1 day
6.5
6.5

As a **Senior PCB / Electronics Engineer** with an extensive background in **technical documentation**, I believe I am well-suited to handle your project. Throughout my career, I have meticulously reviewed and analyzed complex PCB designs and relevant documents like Gerbers/drills, BOM/CPL, and previous engineer review summaries. This experience aligns seamlessly with your need for a **detailed and in-depth** review before manufacturing. Moreover, my adeptness with important components like the **Taoglas TMJ6049BGNL** RJ45, **Silvertel Ag9905MT** PoE module, **ST25R100-CMET**, **TPS2121**, and **C109 KEMET A700X107M010ATE015** PoE output capacitor further enhances my expertise for this particular project. My approach is thorough yet concise, ensuring timely delivery without compromising on quality. Understanding the gravity of these prototypes for you and the need for another perspective, rest assured that I will have all eyes on the board to identify any potential risks that might jeopardize their functionality or assembly. Choose me_today, choose confidence.
£60 GBP in 1 day
5.6
5.6

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ INDEPENDENT PCB REVIEW I’m interested in providing the focused second opinion you’re looking for. I understand this is not a redesign or a DRC exercise—the goal is to independently identify any genuine manufacturing/bring-up risks that could affect the first five Rev B.1 boards and give you a clear YES/NO recommendation. I have practical PCB/electronics experience across mixed-signal designs, power supplies, digital interfaces, MCU hardware and RF/NFC circuits. I can review native KiCad 10 projects and work directly from the schematic, PCB, BOM/CPL, Gerbers and previous review history. I would specifically cross-check the high-risk areas you listed: ESP32-S3 power/boot/USB, PoE isolation and power path, W5500/crystal/magnetics, TPS2121 muxing, ADS1232 analogue section, ST25R100/NFC, critical footprints, polarity, BOM-to-footprint compatibility and manufacturing details. I’ll focus on issues that genuinely matter—not suggest changes simply because I would route something differently. My deliverable will be concise: blockers, significant risks, recommended first-article checks, and the requested final YES/NO: would I manufacture these exact files? I can start with the native KiCad project and supporting review files.
£135 GBP in 7 days
5.7
5.7

Hello, I’m an experienced PCB/embedded hardware engineer with hands-on experience in ESP32, W5500 Ethernet, PoE, USB, power management, and mixed-signal PCBs. I can review your native KiCad 10 files independently, focusing on critical hardware, footprints, power, PoE/Ethernet, NFC, ADC, BOM compatibility, and manufacturing risks. I’ll provide a concise list of genuine issues and a clear YES/NO recommendation for manufacturing the 5 prototypes. I can start immediately.
£135 GBP in 7 days
5.6
5.6

INDEPENDENT PCB REVIEW Hi, I am an electronics/PCB engineer experienced with ESP32 hardware, Ethernet/W5500, USB-C, PoE/power-path design, precision analog interfaces, NFC/RFID, and mixed-signal multilayer PCBs. I regularly review completed boards before fabrication, focusing on issues that can cause boot failure, damaged parts, wrong pinouts, assembly problems, or difficult bring-up rather than subjective routing preferences. Approach: ✅ I will review the native KiCad 10 schematic/PCB, BOM/CPL, Gerbers, and the previous review independently, without assuming its conclusions are correct. ✅ I will focus on ESP32-S3 boot/USB, W5500 crystal and Ethernet mapping, PoE isolation, TPS2121 power switching, ADS1232/load-cell circuitry, ST25R100/NFC, critical footprints, polarity, and BOM compatibility. ✅ I will flag only genuine manufacturing blockers or meaningful prototype risks and recommend practical first-article tests for the five boards. ✅ I will finish with a clear YES/NO answer on whether I would personally send the exact files for prototype manufacture. Questions: ✅ Can you provide the complete KiCad 10 project together with BOM/CPL and the Rev B → B.1 correction summary? ✅ Are the exact Taoglas, Silvertel, ST25R100, TPS2121, and KEMET part numbers already locked in the BOM? ✅ Do you want the review limited to electrical/manufacturing risk, or should I also check antenna/matching assumptions for the external NFC interface? Best, Yaroslav
£135 GBP in 7 days
5.7
5.7

Hi, how are you doing? I went through your project description and I can help you in your project. your project requirements perfectly match my expertise. We are a team of Electrical and Electronics engineers, we have successfully completed 1000+ Projects for multiple regular clients from OMAN, UK, USA, Australia, Canada, France, Germany, Lebanon and many other countries. We are providing our services in following areas: Antenna Design (CST, HFSS) Embedded C Programming. VHDL/Verilog, Quartus/Vivado, LabVIEW/ Multisim/PSPICE/VLSI MATLAB/SIMULINK Network Simulator NS2/NS3 Microcontroller like Arduino, Raspberry Pi, FPGA, AVR, PIC, STM32 and ESP32. IDEs like Keil MDK V5, ATmel studio and MPLab XC8. PLCs / SCADA PCB Designing Proteus, Eagle, KiCAD and Altium IOT Technologies like Ethernet, GSM GPRS. HTTP Restful APIs connection for IOT Communications. Also, we have good command over report writing, I can show you many samples of our previous reports. Kindly consider us for your project and text me so that we can further discuss specifically about your project's main goals and requirements.
£135 GBP in 7 days
5.9
5.9

With over X years of experience in circuit design and PCB layout, I believe I'm the perfect fit for your project. Having read through the entire project brief carefully, I understand that you need someone who can meticulously analyze your PCB's design without altering it unnecessarily, and that's what I excel at. As an independent engineer, my track record includes numerous collaborations on projects with similar scope and complexity. But beyond just the technical aspects, I prioritise trust and transparency - it seems this is exactly what you are looking for too. You want an unbiased evaluation that verifies the safety of your PCB before making an expensive batch and this is precisely what I bring to the table.
£35 GBP in 1 day
5.2
5.2

As an experienced electrical and electronics engineer specializing in PCB design and layout, project 'Independent PCB Pre-Fabrication Peer Review' is right up my alley. I bring a wealth of knowledge to the table having worked extensively with tools like KiCad, Altium Designer, EasyEDA, and Multisim. My aim is always to ensure the designs I work on are reliable, efficient, and safe to use. Drawing from my expertise, it's crucial to have a fresh set of eyes for your KiCad board review. I understand that while the previous independent evaluation concluded a green light for prototype assembly, we cannot rely solely on their feedback. This is where I come in - detecting any potential risks or areas for improvement that could hamper performance or reliability of the produced boards. From your detailed description of what you need checked on the board, I understand the complexity of this project and will approach it seriously and meticulously. Your main interests: failures, damages, unreliable USB/Ethernet/PoE functionality aligns with my key competencies. In particular, I will painstakingly analyze the power systems (ESP32-S3-WROOM-1-N16R8 implementation), PoE's isolation clearance and TPS2121 USB/PoE power mux functionalities since they play a critical role in sustaining stable operation.
£135 GBP in 7 days
5.3
5.3

Hello, My name is Collins and am an embedded engineer. Based on my experience, a fresh pair of eyes before ordering prototype fabrication is essential for avoiding costly spin cycles. As a Senior Electronics Engineer experienced in multi-layer PCB design using KiCad, I can conduct a focused, independent review of your SP-MB1 Rev B.1 board within your budget and timeline. Answers to Your Specific Application Questions: PCB/Electronics Experience: Over 8 years of hardware design, mixed-signal PCB layout, and pre-production prototype validation for industrial automation and IoT devices. Domain Experience: Hands-on experience with ESP32-S3 hardware (boot strapping/USB-C), W5500 SPI Ethernet with integrated magnetics, isolated PoE power architectures (Silvertel/TPS2121 power-path management), precision strain-gauge ADCs (ADS1232), and 13.56 MHz NFC matching networks. KiCad 10 Compatibility: Yes, fully setup to open, inspect, and evaluate native KiCad projects, schematics, and layout layers directly. Design Reviews: Regularly perform independent peer reviews, schematic audits, and DFM/DFA checks for prototype spin readiness. Clear Recommendation: I will deliver a concise list of actionable risks, first-article bring-up tests, and a direct YES/NO manufacturing recommendation. Ready to receive the KiCad files and review package to verify your prototype spin! Best regards..
£155 GBP in 7 days
4.8
4.8

With a rich background in circuit design and electrical engineering, I bring valuable skills to your project, as evident from your comprehensive electronics design description. Having worked extensively in PCB layout and keenly analyzed complex circuits similar to yours, I am equipped with the ability to meticulously scrutinize your design while keeping in mind the dire consequents of any errors. What sets me apart is my hands-on experience with intricate components such as the Taoglas TMJ6049BGNL RJ45, Silvertel Ag9905MT PoE module, ST25R100-CMET, TPS2121, and C109 KEMET A700X107M010ATE015 PoE output capacitor that feature on your board. My expertise allows a detailed evaluation of their correct implementation and any potential issues that may arise during manufacturing or performance, aligning with your core requirements. Moreover, I believe my proficiency in KiCad along with my analytical approach to problem-solving will add value to your project. I understand that you seek confidence in the first batch of prototypes - a need which demands an external evaluation brought by my fresh pair of eyes and critical thinking. In summary, I am confident that with my skill set and experience matching your project requirements closely, I can deliver the insights you are seeking for enhanced confidence in delivering a high-quality product.
£135 GBP in 7 days
4.9
4.9

INDEPENDENT PCB REVIEW I’m an electronics/PCB engineer experienced with mixed-signal embedded boards, ESP32 systems, power supplies, Ethernet, RF/NFC and production-oriented PCB reviews. I can review the native KiCad 10 project directly, including schematic, PCB, BOM/CPL and manufacturing files. I’ll focus on genuine prototype risks rather than redesigning the board simply because I would route something differently. My review will specifically check: * ESP32-S3 power, boot/reset and USB * W5500, crystal, magnetics and RJ45 mapping * PoE isolation, power path and TPS2121 muxing * ADS1232/load-cell analogue section * ST25R100 antenna/matching implementation * Critical footprints, polarity and exact MPN compatibility * BOM/CPL/PCB consistency and obvious assembly/DFM risks I have experience reviewing completed PCB designs before fabrication and understand that ERC/DRC passing does not guarantee electrical correctness. I’ll provide a concise list of any genuine blockers and significant risks, recommended first-article checks, and a clear final answer: **YES** – I would manufacture the five boards, or **NO** – with the exact reason and required correction. The previous review and Rev B.1 changes will be useful context, but I’ll independently verify the important points rather than assuming they are correct.
£135 GBP in 7 days
4.4
4.4

INDEPENDENT PCB REVIEW Hi, I’ve carefully read and understood the requirements. I have hands-on experience with ESP32, Ethernet/W5500, PoE, USB, power management, NFC, mixed-signal circuits, and multilayer PCB design. I can review the KiCad 10 schematic/PCB, BOM/CPL, Gerbers, and previous review notes, focusing on genuine manufacturing, assembly, and bring-up risks rather than just DRC. I’ll provide a concise list of any critical issues, first-article test recommendations, and a clear **YES/NO** manufacturing recommendation. You can also check my portfolio for my previous ESP32, NFC, and multilayer PCB projects. Best regards, Ahmed
£135 GBP in 7 days
4.6
4.6

INDEPENDENT PCB REVIEW Experience: Embedded hardware & PCB design background spanning mixed-signal, power management, and industrial microcontrollers. Key Domains: Direct hands-on work with ESP32 architectures (boot/strapping/USB), isolated PoE (Silvertel modules), Ethernet PHY/W5500 routing, TPS-series power multiplexing, precision low-noise ADCs (ADS series), and 13.56 MHz NFC matching networks. KiCad 10 Native: Yes, fully equipped to review native KiCad 10 project files, schematics, board layout, DRC rules, and manufacturing outputs. Pre-Production Reviews: Regularly perform independent third-party design audits focusing on silicon survival, boot integrity, power-rail handoffs, footprint/pinout anomalies, and assembly showstoppers rather than stylistic rewiring. Clear Verdict: Yes, you will receive a straightforward YES/NO manufacturing recommendation with a categorized risk breakdown (blocking issues vs. bench-level first-article verification points). Ready to review the KiCad archive, BOM/CPL, and change logs within your £20–£30 budget. Are the five prototypes powered primarily via bench supply for initial bring-up, or straight into live PoE?
£200 GBP in 15 days
4.9
4.9

Hello Sir/Madam, I understand your requirements and I can review your 4-layer PCB before manufacturing. I have experience in electronics, PCB design, embedded systems, power circuits, and mixed-signal projects, and I can work with KiCad 10 files. I can check the ESP32, PoE, Ethernet/W5500, USB, NFC, ADC/load-cell section, footprints, BOM, and other important parts. I look forward to working with you. Let’s connect in the chatbox for further discussions. Thank You. Dr. Divya.
£135 GBP in 4 days
4.2
4.2

Gilberdyke, United Kingdom
Payment method verified
Member since Apr 15, 2024
£20-250 GBP
£10-20 GBP
£20-250 GBP
£20-250 GBP
₹12500-37500 INR
£20-250 GBP
$80-100 USD
$15-25 AUD / hour
£20-250 GBP
₹12500-37500 INR
₹12500-37500 INR
₹12500-37500 INR
$30-250 USD
$30-250 USD
$250-750 USD
$5000-10000 USD
$250-750 USD
£20-250 GBP
₹10000-15000 INR
₹12500-37500 INR
₹12500-37500 INR
₹600-1500 INR
₹1500-12500 INR
€30-250 EUR